Hernandez reasoned that mere court sanction out-of a sexual commitment you certainly will never be truly the only research that a person is a real and you will moral citizen
For some reason my personal proposal goes against the first and you will important establishment out of wedding, but even in the event we are in favor of relationships, as it is installing of men just who build statutes for all those, we want to quietly imagine mans genuine disease. Considering you to definitely rules derives out-of reality, these guys possess joined right here to enter a composition hence wipes brush the fresh new errors of the past and you may tries an alternative highway money for hard times, [thus] it is important that they judiciously research this new conditions of our landscaping and arrive at the conclusion that there exists things from inside the our life plus our world that we can not during the in any manner personal the sight, we have to deal with valiantly. 51
By asserting that a beneficial disjuncture stayed ranging from legislators’ beliefs and you may “societal fact,” Hernandez debated that she is actually attacking to possess Cubans who had been not commonly considered type sexual propriety and you may, for this reason, was in fact unjustly disenfranchised
You will find visited the Installation so you can sparingly safeguard, on the better of my function, brand new Cuban girl, this new married woman, the newest single lady, the new light lady, the latest black lady, female of all the categories. I have to say that there are a great number of Cuban feamales in tough and you can embarrassing issues, who happen to be just like the respectable so that as worthy of quality because is almost every other females, that just since she actually is inside a free of charge commitment, doesn’t mean that individuals should consider their and her family unit members depraved. 52
Twenty-two outside of the sixty-half dozen Construction players likely to the newest concept chosen so you can approve Hernandez’s proposition. Most of people that chosen when you look at the like reasoned so it perform oblige guys for the consensual unions in order to satisfy a similar commitments and you will responsibilities you to partnered people was indeed destined to fulfill and you can, therefore, manage manage all women and kids. Particularly, progressive Construction user Capablanca contended you to “though it [Hernandez’s amendment] appears paradoxical, from the being…a strike with the wedding, it is a safeguards of it.” 53 He informed me, “When people know that he’s accountable for people that have who he has got a consensual union and for the college students you to definitely effects from the 100 % free unions, then they will not practice consensual unions however in marriage.” 54 Capablanca depicted males as the almost naturally irresponsible, and implied that ladies requisite State defense against them. Other people echoed their rationale.
not, more Set-up people, progressives and you can traditionals, balked from the Hernandez’s idea, arguing it was maybe not conducive in order to democratic progress and you will create offer rights and privileges to help you undeserving, immoral residents. Old-fashioned Set up user Cortina led good spirited endeavor against Hernandez’s proposition, framing his dissent once the a combat having modernity, progress, and you may society. The guy said that a constitutional ensure to look at consensual unions equivalent to court marriages do basically upload Cuba out of toward an appropriate road divergent regarding compared to “all civilized places in the world” and “destroy…the matrimonial program, and make [it] completely inadequate.” 55 Cortina prophesied, “When it modification had been acknowledged, we possibly may produce a large confusion from inside the courtroom wedded life, therefore we perform do the outcomes of the governmental wave hence we have only lived owing to, so you can sectors in our emotional and you will loved ones existence, [sectors] and that won’t need to become switched regarding the revolutionary and you can perturbing way that is recommended.” 56 To possess Cortina, Pasadena escort the brand new 1933 trend was a political wave, and you may further change should only affect politics: Societal activities shall be left by yourself.